Moodle VS Blackboard – Who’s the winner?
Inspite of being a paid learning management system, Blackboard rocks the boat when it comes to a number of organizations it holds under the belt for larger FTE’s (full-time employees.)
I am sure you too would have gotten surprised looking at the graph. This certainly doesn’t mean that Blackboard has more users than Moodle. As of April 2017, Moodle has 101,869,024 runs in 235 countries. (Source: Moodle). So it depends on what a particular organization is looking for and accordingly gets the learning management system which fits them.
Moodle vs Blackboard
Moodle is majorly used in the educational sector. Having said that, the first thing anybody looks for is the price & Moodle certainly takes everyone hands down. Moodle is a free open source software, but one can not neglect the fact that its not ready to use software. Moodle looks confusing when used by novice users because of the clutter of system functionality.
Here are the three ways by which one will be hurt if they pick this free LMS and then try to customize it,
- Customize it through Moodle directly for a hefty price
- Customize it through Moodle Partners like Moodlerooms
- Customize it through in-house developers
All in all, one has to pay, now or later if they need something good.
Blackboard, on the other hand, is a paid LMS and can be used right out of the box which is much easier and hassle free. Blackboard cost per student or its pricing structure can be checked with them directly. Blackboard is made for schools, government, and businesses as well.
Moodle vs Blackboard comparison chart
|Define User Roles||No||Yes|
Course Development feature
|Course Authoring Tool||Yes||No|
These are the list for the couple of features which one looks at when buying an LMS. There are a lot more features and functions which are not listed here. (You may also check moodle vs canvas.)
Shortcomings: Moodle vs Blackboard
Blackboard is a bit outdated but is high on pricing, on the other hand, Moodle can be easy on pockets but UI is just not user-friendly.
Moodle: With the free Moodle version, you would see ads on the UI and this would translate into bad user experience for your users. You’ll have to pay a nominal monthly fee to remove the ads. Moreover, Moodle for School plans are primarily intended for usage of up to 500 users. And this is a setback given Moodle’s speciality of being an educational LMS. Educational institutes usually require a solution for over 500 users, and this puts them in a fix.
Blackboard: Many a times it is reported that Blackboard can be buggy. Users have reported Blackboard pages not loading correctly or fully sometimes. Also, unlike other mainstream LMSs, it doesn’t integrate with Google Apps and many other platforms.
Takeaway: Moodle vs Blackboard
Moodle vs Blackboard, there is no clear winner as no product is perfect. However, in the opn source LMS range these two are often the front runners for your companies. Both, are individually priced and should be compared through a series of strategic decisions that are specific to your organizational needs, while keeping your learners in mind.
In the Moodle vs Blackboard tug of war, we feel its not wise to compare them against each other. Both of them are made for different uses. Blackboard prioritizes on providing better assessment tools for teachers, while Moodle focuses more on engagement tools for learners.
Paradiso LMS is best of both the worlds & currently, is used by 1 million+ users and is known for easy to use UI and cost effective solution.
If you are still thinking about other LMS’s, well here is a quick link for Paradiso LMS.